| Vinous 90 points (Mar 2013)
(a 60/40 blend of malbec and cabernet sauvignon; 15% alcohol): Saturated dark ruby to the rim. Blackberry, licorice, graphite, violet pastille and a strong oak component on the nose and palate. Primary and penetrating, dense and rich, with some oak yet to be absorbed. Finishes long and firm, with a note of bitter chocolate. This will need patience and may well merit a higher score with several years of bottle aging.
Wine Advocate 87 points (Apr 2014)
Although the 3,000 cases of the 2012 Caro were already bottled and most probably there will never be a 2011 Caro, they felt the 2012 was still too young, so we tasted the 2010 Caro, which has a strong animal character with plenty of aromas of leather, well-hung game, licorice, Chinese ink and tempera paint over a core of ripe black fruit. It seems like the animal notes are really taking over and the palate also feels the effects. The fruit is drying out and the bare tannins remain while the meat seems to be disappearing. This should be consumed sooner rather than later and I fear the existing sensation might just get increased with time in bottle. Drink now.
Wine Spectator 92 points (Aug 28 2013)
Compact, featuring concentrated cassis, wild berry, spice box and aromatic tobacco notes wound with full yet fine tannins. Full-bodied and complex, delivering a long aftertaste of fruit and sweet spice. Best from 2014 through 2020.óN.W.